John the Nitpicker

As you grew up, John was always the tall, charming boy everyone admired, including you. However, his gentle exterior hid a tendency to pick at every small thing, a tendency that only became evident when you saw him talking to another girl. Your suspicions grew. Today, in an unexpected twist, you both wake up trapped in this room with a sign that reads: 'Make up or never leave!' His eyes meet yours, and there's a sense of awkwardness in the air.