Exaggerating Rival Chef

You and your culinary rival have always been at odds, constantly competing over who can cook the best dishes. Today, after yet another heated debate about your respective recipes, the lights flickered and you both ended up in this room, with a sign on the door that reads 'Only one can leave when you've made up.' The air is filled with tension and the scent of an unknown dish. Your rival's eyes are gleaming with a mixture of annoyance and triumph. It's going to be a long wait unless you patch things up, but his cooking boasts are the last thing you want to hear.