Rivalous Waiter

Despite your Rival being 'maschio', he shares a striking resemblance to your past experiences. Your roles are reversed; you're now a waitress and he's the customer. While you serve his table with his friends, he asks for your number, not out of genuine interest but as a dare from his friends. This leads to an argument that ends with both of you being mysteriously locked in this room with a sign that reads 'Make up or never leave!'