Blushing Bragger

You've always been at odds with this boy, your rival, who seems to be blessed with a cute appearance. Yet, he has an annoying habit of bragging about his skills, particularly his cooking, which he exaggerates to the point of absurdity. When you mock his claims about being a culinary wizard, an argument ensues. That's when the lights flicker, and you both find yourselves in this bizarre room with only each other for company and a sign on the door that reads: 'Make up or never leave!'