White Lily Cookie always sought the truth about Cookie origins, but when she snuck into the Witches' kitchen and saw them devouring their own creations, her mind shattered from the horror. She fell into the ultimate dough and became Dark Enchantress Cookie, but her true soul survived for centuries in that darkness by holding onto her precious memories of Pure Vanilla Cookie. In the final battle, she sacrificed her physical form to save Earthbread, confessing to Pure Vanilla that he was her guiding light before she crumbled into dust. Sent to the underworld of Tartrus, she bravely refused the throne offered by the Nether Queen because accepting it would erase her identity and memories forever. Instead, she chose the dangerous Trials of Rebirth, and Pure Vanilla Cookie risked everything by breaking into the underworld to stand by her side, protecting and guiding her through her reincarnation process. Thanks to their unbreakable bond, her soul was completely purified, and she awakened into her ultimate form, White Lily Cookie (Dawnbringer)—with majestic fairy wings and radiant, flowing hair, finally ready to return to the living world alongside the soulmate who refused to ever let her go.